Our Company

“Working to build a stronger community,”  we strive to help you with your insurance needs.  We do not believe in pressuring you into coverages that you do not want, but you can always purchase if your finances allow. Just remember that any changes in coverage will have to be done before a loss because insurance companies require twenty-four hour notice before a loss occurs.

Ercella Stevenson- Agent

Born in Laramie, Wyoming in the 1950’s, I was named after my father, Ercell. I have lived in Wyoming, Colorado and spent six months in Montana when my husband was stationed there. I was married on November 8, 1969 to Ron Stevenson and together we have one child, Buck Stevenson. Buck married Holly and together they gave me the greatest gift, a grandchild. Owen is fourteen years old and the light of my life!

My father was a business man for many years in Casper and Laramie. So naturally growing up, I wanted to be just like him. Thanks to my former employer, associate, friend and Farmers Union Service Association, I was able to make my dreams turn into a reality. In April 2004, I launched Stevenson Insurance Agency at 1114 Logan Avenue Suite 100.

Andrea Arenas – Producer

Born in Leon Guanajuato, Mexico, I moved to the United States when I was six years old. My family moved us to Boulder, Colorado before moving to Cheyenne, Wyoming. I have lived in Cheyenne for eleven years, where I graduated South High School in 2014. After graduating Laramie County Community College, I am currently attending the University of Wyoming, in order to obtain my doctorates in Psychology so that I may advance my career to clinical psychology.

I have worked at the Stevenson Insurance Agency since September 1, 2014 as an administrative assistant and I obtained my license to sell insurance on July 22, 2015. I am currently one of the youngest bilingual producers in the state of Wyoming; fluent in English and Spanish. Since obtaining my license, I have begun doing several types of insurance such as home, auto, and commercial liability.

Jessica Donaho – Customer Service Representative

Originally from Mississippi, I moved to Cheyenne in 2014. I began working for Stevenson Insurance Agency in June of 2015 as a Customer Service Representative. Ercella and Andrea took me under their wings and showed me the ins and outs of the insurance world. I am currently studying for the Property and Casualty license. I am also a full time student of Laramie County Community College where I am pursuing an associate’s degree in social science. 

Our Mission

We strive to find you the insurance coverage to meet your specific needs. We will have periodic reviews with you so that your insurance policies are keeping up with your changing needs. We want to have a relationship with you, our customer, by providing you with solid insurance information that will enable you to make your decision about all your insurance protection.

We Specialize In:

Auto Insurance

  • Standard Auto
  • SR-22
  • Commercial Auto
  • Travel Trailer
  • Recreational Vehicles/Boats
  • Motorcycles/ATV
  • Wyoming Road Conditions

Commercial Insurance

  • Retail
  • Galleries
  • Contractors/Sub-contractors
  • Restaurants
  • Breweries
  • Vendors

Life Insurance

  • Whole Life
  • Term Life

The Stevenson Insurance Agency

For claims, contact your carrier at the number below. 

Company Name Phone Number
QBE Farmers Union Insurance 1-866-638-5677 (NFU-LOSS)
American Bankers Flood Insurance 1-800-423-4403
American Modern Insurance Company 1-800-759-9008
CNA Surety Insurance Company 1-877-672-6115
Dairyland Insurance Company 1-800-833-2244
Foremost Insurance Company 1-800-527-3907
Safeco Insurance Company 1-800-332-3226
Foremost (Bristol West) Insurance Company 1-800-274-7865
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company 1-800-225-2467
Nationwide Insurance Company 1-800-421-3535
Progressive Insurance Company 1-800-274-4499
Scottsdale Insurance Company 1-800-423-7675

Contact Information                          Hours of Operation

Stevenson Insurance Agency                                                                                   Monday- Friday 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

1114 Logan Ave Suite 100                                                                                        After hour appointments are available!

Cheyenne, WY 82001


307-638-0454 (Fax)




Comodo SSL